Once your licence is granted, you’ll be handed a set of conditions setting out how you must operate. Some are straightforward and sensible. Others can impose considerable costs or place significant restrictions on your business. But just how far can a Licensing Authority go in deciding what those conditions should be?

The Civic Government (Scotland) Act 1982 gives Licensing Authorities considerable discretion to impose conditions, but that discretion is not unlimited. An authority must work within the powers Parliament has given it, and even a condition introduced with the best intentions can be unlawful.

What the Law Allows

The 1982 Act allows Licensing Authorities to establish standard conditions for different licence types, and to impose additional conditions when granting or renewing individual licences, provided those additional conditions are reasonable.

This flexibility exists because different licensing activities require different approaches. For example, a street trader will probably have different requirements from a taxi operator or someone running licensed premises.

However, this does not mean the authority can impose absolutely any restriction it wishes. Conditions must fall within the Authority’s legal powers and the exercise of those powers must be reasonable.

The Type of Condition Matters

The 1982 Act establishes three categories of licensing conditions.

  • Mandatory conditions, which are required by legislation and Licensing Authorities cannot simply disregard them.
  • Standard conditions, which are set locally and generally apply to a particular licence type. Standard conditions cannot conflict with mandatory conditions. 
  • Additional conditions, which can be attached to individual licences, allowing the authority to address the particular circumstances.

Licensing Authorities have different levels of discretion depending on which of these types of conditions are involved. 

For example, the legislation allows for standard conditions to be varied or disapplied when granting or renewing a particular licence. This provides some flexibility. So, if a standard condition doesn’t make sense for your business, you can ask for an exception to be considered. There’s no guarantee the authority will agree, but the law allows it to depart from its usual requirements.

There’s also a difference between a legally enforceable condition and something merely recommended in government guidance. A recommendation doesn’t automatically become law simply because it appears in an official circular.

When the Law Says No

In some cases, the law prevents certain conditions from being imposed. A useful example comes from taxi and private hire licensing. Under section 20 of the 1982 Act, regulations can prescribe conditions that Licensing Authorities must impose, along with conditions they’re expressly prohibited from imposing. The 1986 Regulations, governing taxi and private hire licensing conditions, contain several prohibitions like this.

The 1986 Regs prohibit conditions requiring taxi or private hire licence holders to live within their licensing area. Nor can conditions restrict those licence holders from undertaking other employment or business. The regulations also prevent restrictions on radios and other external communication equipment in private hire cars. These aren’t simply conditions that might be considered unfair or unreasonable. They are specifically prohibited by law.

Even if it believes a particular condition would make good local policy, a Licensing Authority has no power to impose a condition if the law has prohibited such a condition in the first place.

When a Sensible Condition Goes Too Far

A useful example comes from a 2023 Court of Session case concerning Edinburgh’s short-term let licensing policy, Averbuch and Others.

One of the matters challenged was a condition Edinburgh Council had imposed a requiring suitable floor coverings, such as carpets, in properties used for secondary letting. The intention was to reduce noise disturbance for neighbouring residents. On the face of it, that sounds reasonable enough. 

The problem was that the authority applied the condition across all secondary lets, including ground-floor flats and detached houses where the same noise concerns might not exist.

Lord Braid found the blanket requirement irrational and, where it could impose significant expense without good reason, oppressive. The court wasn’t saying that carpets could never be required though. The problem lay in how widely the authority had chosen to apply the condition. Indeed, Edinburgh subsequently removed the blanket condition while retaining the ability to consider floor-covering requirements in individual cases.

Licensing Authorities are entitled to set standards, but having a legitimate concern doesn’t automatically justify imposing the same requirement on every business, regardless of its circumstances. A condition that makes perfect sense in one situation might be difficult to justify in another.

What If You Think a Condition Is Unlawful?

The first thing to understand is that you shouldn’t simply dismiss or disregard it. Failing to comply with a licence condition can be a criminal offence, although the legislation provides a defence where the licence holder can prove they took all due diligence to prevent the breach.

There can also be consequences for the licence itself. The law allows a Licensing Authority to suspend or revoke a licence where a condition has been breached. A criminal conviction isn’t necessarily required before the authority can take that action.

So, even if you believe a condition is unlawful or unreasonable, disregarding it can create further problems. A better starting point is to question the condition through the appropriate licensing process.

You may be able to ask for a standard condition to be varied or disapplied when your licence is being granted or renewed. If it’s an additional condition, you can question whether the authority has properly justified imposing it.

There are also legal routes for challenging licensing decisions. The law provides a right of appeal to the Sheriff Court, including on grounds of legal error or unreasonable exercise of discretion. In some circumstances, the legality of the wider policy behind a decision may also be examined as part of a challenge. The appropriate procedure depends on the decision, the legislation involved and the issues being raised.

If you’re faced with a condition that seems unreasonable, don’t assume it’s lawful simply because the council has published it. Equally, don’t assume it’s unlawful just because it’s expensive, inconvenient or different from what another authority requires.

Establish what type of condition it is and what legal power allows the authority to impose it.

There is, after all, an important difference between the standards a Licensing Authority believes a business ought to meet and the conditions it is legally entitled to impose.

\