Waiting for a decision on a civic licence application can be one of the most frustrating parts of operating a business. You’ve done the preparation, committed the finances, and in the case of new grants, you’re stuck sitting on your hands unable to trade.
The Civic Government (Scotland) Act 1982 places strict statutory time limits on the determination of applications. If the Licensing Authority misses those deadlines, there are legal consequences. The passage of time carries a legal weight entirely separate from the actual merits of your application.
The Statutory Clock
The legislation establishes a two-stage process for handling applications.
- Stage One: The Licensing Authority must consider your application within three months of the relevant date.
- Stage Two: It must reach a final decision within a further six months, starting from the end of that initial three month period.
Put together, the ordinary statutory determination period is nine months.
There is, however, an important difference between “consideration” and “determination”. The law doesn’t require the authority to grant or refuse the application in those first three months. Nor does the Act spell out precisely what steps amount to consideration. This can sometimes make it difficult to establish exactly what the authority has done to satisfy that first stage.
When Does the Clock Actually Start?
The “relevant date” is ordinarily the date the application is made.
In practice, Licensing Authorities generally require an application to be complete and competently lodged before treating the statutory clock as having started. Simply submitting an application form and paying the fee may not be sufficient if required information or supporting documentation is missing.
Schedule 1 sets out the requirements for making an application, including the prescribed form, signature, applicable fee and specified information. Applications can also be submitted electronically where the authority accepts them under paragraph 16A.
There is, however, an important difference between an incomplete application and one that has been properly made but is still awaiting administrative processing. The statutory starting date is determined by the requirements of the Act, not simply by when the council decides to acknowledge or process the application.
There’s also an important qualification regarding HMRC tax conditionality. For certain applications, including those relating to taxi and private hire drivers, booking offices and scrap metal dealers, the authority may be legally prevented from considering the application until the necessary tax-check requirements have been satisfied. Where that restriction applies, the starting date is postponed until the authority is no longer prevented from proceeding.
The practical advice is therefore to make sure everything required for a competent application has been submitted and to obtain confirmation of the date the Licensing Authority has recorded it as lodged. Where that date differs from the actual submission date, it may be worth establishing why.
Can the Authority Extend the Deadline?
Not without the sheriff’s approval.
A Licensing Authority can apply to the sheriff for an extension of the determination period. It must make that application within the six-month period provided for reaching the final decision.
The sheriff may grant an extension and determine its length, but only where satisfied that there is good reason to do so. You, as the licence applicant, have the right to be a party to those proceedings.
A licensing officer telling you that the council is running behind schedule is not the same as obtaining a statutory extension. Administrative difficulties might explain a delay, but they do not automatically extend the legal deadline.
The Deemed Grant: When the Deadline Expires
The legislation provides for what is known as a “deemed grant”. If the Licensing Authority fails to reach a final decision before the statutory determination period expires, and no court extension applies, your application is legally deemed to have been granted or renewed. The legislation also covers deemed variations of licence terms in applicable circumstances. For an ordinary grant or renewal, a deemed licence generally remains in force for one year, while different duration rules apply to temporary licences.
This is a significant legal consequence. You do not need to prove that the committee would otherwise have approved your application. The deemed grant arises because the authority failed to reach its decision within the statutory period.
However, a deemed grant is not immunity from the licensing regime. Statutory requirements and applicable licensing conditions remain relevant, and the authority retains its lawful powers to vary, suspend or revoke licences.
Before you start trading on the basis of a deemed grant, make absolutely sure the dates have been calculated correctly, that the application was competently made and that no court extension or other statutory provision changes your position.
Renewals: Don’t Risk the Grace Period
Renewals are slightly different, but they carry an important protection. If you apply to renew your licence before it expires, the existing licence ordinarily continues in force while the council determines your application, including during any relevant appeal period where applicable. This prevents administrative delays from unnecessarily shutting down an established business simply because the authority has not yet reached a decision.
There is also a limited provision for late renewals. A Licensing Authority may, on good cause being shown, treat a renewal application submitted within 28 days after the licence expires as though it had been made before expiry. But this is discretionary. It is not an automatic grace period, and applicants should never assume that a late submission carries the same protection as an on-time renewal.
The statutory clock discussed earlier applies to renewals too, so leaving an application until the last moment can create unnecessary complications. A missing document or an incomplete submission could put the continuation of your existing licence at risk.
Navigating the Delay
The statutory clock discussed applies across a wide range of civic licensing activities, including taxi licensing, street trading and public entertainment. Short-term lets are also governed by the 1982 Act, although their licensing regulations contain some specific provisions of their own. Other licensing regimes, such as alcohol licensing, operate under separate primary legislation and have their own procedures and deadlines.
If your application is stuck in limbo, complaining about council inefficiency is unlikely to achieve much on its own. Instead, establish the legal position. Pin down the date your application was properly made and calculate when the three month and nine month deadlines expire.
As the final deadline approaches, seek written clarification from the licensing department about its anticipated decision date and whether an application has been made to the sheriff for an extension.
Keep copies of your application, submission receipts, fee payments and correspondence. All of these may become important when establishing the chronology.
In civic licensing, there is a fundamental difference between an annoying administrative delay and a failure to meet a statutory deadline. The former may be frustrating, but the latter can have consequences expressly provided by law. Know your dates, and hold the authority to them.